Once there was a man who filmed his vacation.
He went flying down the river in his boat
with his video camera to his eye, making
a moving picture of the moving river
upon which his sleek boat moved swiftly
toward the end of his vacation. He showed
his vacation to his camera, which pictured it,
preserving it forever: the river, the trees,
the sky, the light, the bow of his rushing boat
behind which he stood with his camera
preserving his vacation even as he was having it
so that after he had had it he would still
have it. It would be there. With a flick
of a switch, there it would be. But he
would not be in it. He would never be in it.
Wendell Berry: The Vacation
When I went to Europe for the first time with the Antioch College Choir, I was a card-carrying hippy in my last year of college (1973). I followed the mantra “Be here now” and dismissed the old-fashioned notion of bringing a camera on the trip. I did record those travels faithfully in my journal, which is actually a much more meaningful way to document experience. But years later, I sorely regretted not having a single photo of the trip. Luckily, a fellow student took some photos and posted them on a Website, so I there are maybe five photos with me in them that help me say with certainty: “This happened. And I was there.”
This on my mind at the last day of Flower Piano. By now, I hope you have a picture in your mind of some 12 pianos spread out around the Botanical Garden in Golden Gate Park and people pretty much crowded around each one listening to someone play. I imagine many travel around to at least half, if not all of the 12 pianos and hear some 30 to 40 people playing. (The ones that don’t have a scheduled show at any moment are open to the public and people take turns, usually playing one to three pieces.)
Everything about this is wonderful. On the weekend, the crowds seem to have tripled and there were literally thousands of people milling about, cold fog be damned, listening to the music. The last band I heard was a great swing band and looking around me, some people were dancing, some sitting on blankets with food, some standing before strolling on. Again, except for a little sunshine, it couldn’t be better.
Are you picturing a “but…” coming? Good guess! And here it is.
At any one piano, it seems like over half the crowd has their phones up videoing the player. Now imagine having listened to some 30 or 40 people playing three or more pieces each and you have 100 videos captured on your phone. So my two questions are this:
1) When is anyone going to ever watch these again? How much time do you have? If you decide to delete some, you still have to watch some of each and how long will that take? And how many will you keep and why and again, when are you ever going to listen to them again? And why would you, when you can probably hear the same piece played much better by someone on Youtube? If your friend was playing, okay, I get it, but that certainly couldn’t have been the case as I looked around at all the phones in the air.
2) Theoretically, you can still listen attentively with your hand up in the air with the phone in it. But I suspect, like Wendell Berry’s vacationer, that some part of you feels like you don’t have to listen that hard because, hey, you can always watch it later. I suspect it steals a bit of your motivation and ability to be wholly present, to “be here now” and really savor the sounds floating up into the redwoods, cushioned by all the surrounding greenery and enjoyed in company with a hundred living begins gathered up in the music’s arms.
As noted in the next entry, one of those videos opened up a wonderful conversation, but I’m sure that’s the exception rather than the rule.
And so the Aesopian moral, of which I need reminders as much as anyone. Some kind of documentation, be it a photo or video, is natural to our species that lives in the moment and reflects on it, sometimes all at once. But not all documentation is created equal—a journal entry, a poem, a piece of art, a song, even a dance, to preserve an occasion uses so much more of us than a machine can ever grant. By creating something artful inspired by the moment, you are re-creating the beauty and memorability of the moment. And some things are best remembered in the neural folds of our own memory, to be shared over dinners with the friends who were there or told around campfires.
None of this cancels the sincere wonderfulness of this 10-day event. But it is food for thought. To be chewed over on a picnic blanket on the grass listening to a hot swing band.