I like asking directions of live humans before resorting to electronic solutions, but sometimes the technologies manage to combine our human instinct to help each other with reaching the right people. Though I didn’t ask every single person I know in San Francisco, the ones I tend to talk to at least once a week couldn’t help me with my passport dilemma since they hadn’t renewed theirs recently. So for the first time, I put the question out to “hive mind” on Facebook and within a few hours, had some 25 helpful responses, all letting me know that when they renewed, their old passport came back to them in a separate mailing. I got both the needed relief that this would work out, the little dopamine rush of hearing from people I knew (since my Facebook friends are in fact, almost all actual friends and colleagues I know) and yet another affirmation that we are here to be of service.
Like the pleasure the strangers I ask for directions (mostly) feel in being useful and sharing their knowledge to help someone out, we indeed are wired to help. I do an activity in my workshops with 22 instruments in a circle, 11 people seated at them and playing, 11 more in-between each player studying what they’re playing. After playing the piece a few minutes, everyone switches. Those who had observed move to the instrument to their right to play, those who played moved to the right to observe the next instrument in the circle. In this way, by the end, everyone gets to play each of the parts in the piece.
Not only is this musically powerful, experiencing the same piece from 11 different perspectives, but there is a hidden humanitarian message in this structure. Even though all have been prepared in their body and voice to learn each part and studying the next instrument likewise prepares them to play it correctly, still people arrive at the instrument and sometimes struggle with getting the pattern. Invariably, the person who had just played notices and turns back to help them, even though it means they’re losing some observation time.
At the end of the activity, I ask: “Who helped somebody?” “Who received help?” Lots of hands go up. And then I ask, “Why did you help them?” The best answer came from a 10-year-old-girl in a guest class I taught: “So we all could enjoy to the maximum the pleasure of music played well.” Yeah!
Often people note that if the music doesn’t sound good, nobody is happy, so that’s a big motivation to help. Many just say, “Well, of course I’m going to help someone who’s having a little trouble if I know how to help them.” And so on. Affirmation all around that our first instinct is indeed to help.
Then I ask, “Let’s imagine I was grading you on this activity. As we all know, the game of grading mostly works by someone who gets the answer right being rewarded with a letter or number and someone who is struggling being punished with a lower letter or number. So in this game, when you see your classmate struggling, you should feel happy because that will help your grade. And you’d be a little crazy to help them, because hey, you have to watch out for number one and you want to be number one. So the whole dynamic would change. None of you would also play as well because there’d be stress and anxiety about whether you will play each part correctly, which brings you down to the brain stem where fear and survival live and you can’t access the higher emotional and intellectual skills needed to actually play music well, with a relaxed feeling and joy in the mix."
So we should look carefully at the structures and systems we create that promote division, stress, fear, anxiety, that shut down our innate instinct to help each other out. And for what? A report card that no one will ever ask to see again in your entire adult life, that no one will read at your funeral. And replace them with the structures and systems that promote connection, community, comradery, joy and justice.
The hive mind’s generous response to my little dilemma brought such sweet honey into my day. All who responded could easily follow their impulses to help. But what if there was a law akin to the one made in Georgia, the one that set it up so black voters would have to stand in long lines in the hot sun and you could be arrested for bringing them a bottle of water. (I am not making this up! The depths of depravity heartless monsters risen to positions of power is beyond human comprehension.) What if you could get in trouble for answering my passport question? How many would do it now?
Luckily, we’re not there yet, but just a reminder to be vigilant about all the systems that reward us for becoming the worst versions of ourselves and punish us for being the best. Meanwhile, think about this little hive mind story to remember that we are essentially good people who are happy and eager to help. And that we all benefit from the good music and sweet honey.
And if you work for the Passport Office, I’m especially counting on you to remember that!