I love the kids at my school. I
love how they’re innocent without being naïve. I love how they’re worldly-wise
without being cynical. I love how they’re willing to take risks in front of
their peers, be it expressing a thought or singing a solo or improvising on a
glockenspiel. I love it that they’re mostly kind and accepting of each other, as
far as their developmental levels allow them. I love their humor, their
seriousness, their ease with adults, their care of plants and animals. I love
all of these things and more.
But in the area of etiquette,
manners, simple grace and courtesy, well, they could use a little work. Okay, a lot of work! The idea of waiting until
two adults stop talking before interrupting, of letting a teacher get through
three sentences of directions without any side-talk or comments on what the
teacher is saying, of restraining themselves from touching or picking up any
instrument in the music room within arm’s reach… well, like I said, a work in progress.
It’s interesting how much more I’m
valuing the simple rituals of grace and courtesy as an older adult. As a
younger one coming to age in the 60’s, we thought it was all superficial
posturing and insincere pretense. A leftover from the bourgeoisie. We didn’t
need these smokescreens of politeness, we would be direct and tell it like it
is.
Turns out that the etymology of
etiquette comes from an 18th century French word meaning of :list of
ceremonial observances at court” and was related to the word “ticket”
(“tiquette”) because little cards saying things like “keep of the grass” were
written and strategically placed to remind people of proper behavior. Isn’t
that interesting? So it turns out that
it was a bourgeois practice coming from the oh-so-proper behavior we
associate with European Court life. No wonder we hippies didn’t care to hold
our pinky out just so while sipping tea!
But when I began to travel around
the world, part of the game was learning the different customs of each place—
the way in Indonesia you don’t sit pointing your feet at someone or step over
instruments or start drinking tea or even noticing that your host has put it in
front of you before they say “Mari.” It became a game of sorts and I began to
realize that these little gestures of agreed-upon customs were the glue that
kept things civil, connected and harmonious. Some are universal— some physical
greetings (a bow, a hand-shake, a high-five, a hug), some form of thank you and
you’re welcome and please—and some are specific— formal and informal pronouns,
the above tea example and more.
And as any notion of a civil
society becomes unglued with the shouting matches of hateful talk shows, the insulting
tweets of a President, the loss of the boundary between appropriate and inappropriate
language and the whole nightmare of cell phone usage, it’s not an easy
atmosphere in which to teach school children grace and courtesy. But perhaps
more important than ever to do so. It’s a new mission for me in my classes, to
be explicit and to practice what was once implicit and understood and walk kids
through the words and gestures like a script in a play, a script with a purpose
of making our time together more pleasant and courteous. It may seem insincere
when a child says “thank you” because the adult is making them, but it is
important, I do believe, for them to practice it nonetheless.
But it also means that when a
child says thank you without prompting, they really mean it. And when this
happened to me three times on Friday after classes I had just taught—one from
an 8th grader, one from a 4th grader and one from a
5-year old (who turned to me as we were walking down the hall and looked me in
the eye and said, “Thank you for teaching me.”), it was a sign that I had done
something right that day. I had taught things worthy of their attention and taught them in such a way
that they meant something to the students. They had both fun and challenge
and the surprise of a success beyond what they thought they could accomplish. While they absolutely deserve some credit (and I often thank kids for the
sincere efforts I see them making), they also recognized that none of it would
have happened without my efforts to give them something worthy of their best
selves. I’ve yet to receive any “Teacher of the Year Awards” that the newspaper
will report, but every time I receive these kind of thank yous—and there have
been many this year—I feel affirmed in the most meaningful way.
If you read my last post, you’ll
understand when I say, “Kerry M. Collier, are you reading this? Might you have
been a little more civil than you were when you called me “trash” for
suggesting that certain people are hiding behind their limited understanding of
their 2nd Amendment rights to avoid facing the reality of children
being shot in school? Was that called for? Oh, by the way, in polite society,
people often say, “I’m sorry. That was unacceptable. Please accept my apology
and let’s see if we can discuss the 2nd Amendment more calmly, with
Grace and Courtesy.” And then I’ll be most happy to talk.
Thank you.